General Statements Concerning
the Broad History of Christian Hymnody

- The hymnody of the early Christian Church was greatly influenced by JEWISH TRADITIONS in both practice and scope. See Ancient Jewish music.

- Christians began to develop their own hymnody after the DESTRUCTION OF THE JEWISH TEMPLE in 70 CE

- The earliest Christian hymns are NEW TESTAMENT HYMNS and are so intricately woven with scripture as to be mostly indistinguishable.

- The earliest Christian hymns probably developed in association with the primitive Eucharist (Lord's Supper) where complete hymns (such as CANTICLES) would have been sung by individuals with the congregation joining in responses.

- After about 300 CE, hymn traditions started developing separately in the Eastern (Greek/Byzantine) and Western (Latin) Churches [See Languages of the Early Church]. After the GREAT SCHISM (1054 CE), the two traditions are totally separate.

- The study of Christian hymnody to around 300 CE is mainly the study of GREEK HYMNODY.

- The study of Christian hymnody between 300 - 900 CE is the study of both GREEK HYMNODY and LATIN HYMNODY. [See Languages of the Early Church]

- The study of GREEK HYMNODY is mainly the study of the hymnody of the GREEK ORTHODOX CHURCH and is associated with the study of BYZANTINE music. However, there are other “orthodox” traditions: COPTIC (Egyptian), SYRIAN, ETHIOPIAN, RUSSIAN, SERBIAN, ARMENIAN....

- The study of Christian hymnody between about 900 - 1500 CE is the study of LATIN HYMNODY in the ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH.

- With the advent of the PROTESTANT REFORMATION in the 1500's, the study of Christian hymnody is mainly the study of PROTESTANT HYMNODY.

- With the success of the PROTESTANT REFORMATION, there was a COUNTER REFORMATION in the ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH which resulted in the COUNCIL OF TRENT in 1545-1563. This codified ROMAN CATHOLIC LITURGY AND MUSIC (including hymnody) until the SECOND VATICAN COUNCIL in 1962-1965. Consequently, the study of ROMAN CATHOLIC HYMNODY from about 1500 to 1965 becomes a specialized study with few major developments (for example the "Cecilia Movement" during the late 19th and early 20th centuries).

- Metrical Psalmody was the mainstay of English hymnody from about 1550 - 1700.

- Isaac Watts was mainly responsible for the introduction and popularization of true hymns in the English Protestant tradition through his paraphrased psalms and hymns [Hymns and Spiritual Songs, 1707; Psalms of David Imitated in the Language of the New Testament - 1719].

- Charles Wesley and those who were influenced by him were responsible for the development of the Evangelical hymn after about 1750.

- By 1830, the popularity of the Evangelical hymn in England gave rise to alarm among the Established Church of England. Through the influence of the Oxford Movement, a new type of Liturgical hymn developed and became the mainstay of non-evangelical churches.

- Early American Protestant hymnody to about 1700 was more or less identical with it's European antecedents, particularly Metrical Psalmody, and Lutheran and Anabaptist hymnody. Lutheran and Anabaptist hymnody have their own specialized traditions because the majority of Lutheran and Anabaptist hymnals were printed in German or other Scandinavian languages. Consequently, the study of American hymnody after about 1700 is primarily the study of hymns in the English language.

- A New England 'Singing School' movement developed after about 1720 in an effort to improve congregational singing. This gave rise to a 'school' of American composers who produced many Singing School manuals.

- Singing Schools became extremely popular throughout New England and eventually spread to the South through the Shenandoah Valley of Virginia as settlers began to move 'westward' after about 1815.

- In America from about 1865-1880, the combination of folk hymnody, camp meeting hymnody, Sunday School hymnody, and popular secular music influenced by American Romanticism came together with the development of the Gospel Song.

- Gospel hymnody became popular in the United States in last decade of the 19th century and grew in popularity through the 1st half of the 20th century in part as a result of the success of the revivalist movement and the success of a plethora of gospel hymn publishing companies. By about 1920, 'gospel hymn' or 'gospel song' was generally recognized as a specific type of hymn associated with a specific style of music (see New Baptist Hymnal, 1926).

- Together, Methodists, Baptists, Presbyterians, Episcopalians, and Lutherans comprised by far the majority of non-Roman Catholic Christian groups. Methodists and Baptists printed gospel songs along with mainline hymns in their hymnals as early as the 1920's. Presbyterians, Episcopalians, and Lutherans did not. Although, it was not uncommon for individual congregations to supplement their 'official' denominational hymnal with one or more of the popular gospel song collections.

- Few great English language mainline hymns were written between about 1900 - 1960 (here we are not considering the gospel hymn tradition). But since about 1965 some of the greatest hymns in the English language have been written -- in EITHER style (mainline or gospel). This period is known as the NEW ENGLISH RENAISSANCE and the phenomenon has also been called the "HYMN EXPLOSION".

- In the early 20th century, Afro-American gospel hymnody was indistinguishable from other gospel hymnody as represented by gospel hymns appearing in print. However after 1930, Afro-American gospel hymnody developed separately with the influence of blues, the introduction of the Hammond Organ, the growth in the popularity of the "Jubilee" style of singing, and the growth of pentecostalism in many Afro-American churches.

- Gospel hymnody grew in popularity during the latter half of the 20th century, paralleling the growth in the number of churches espousing Christian fundamentalism and pentecostalism. A direct outgrowth of this was the creation of a "Contemporary-style" worship service which predominantly uses contemporary-Christian music (see 20th Century Gospel) and praise-and-worship music, both of which evolved from the gospel music tradition.

- After World War II, two separate "communities" in Europe spontaneously created a new type of church song based to a large degree on ancient chant and folk music: the Tieze Community in France and the Iona Community in Scotland. Although there is no connection between these two communities in terms of how they originated, both have explored the traditions of contemplative prayer and meditation as well as experimenting with new musical forms. The congregational song from these two communities has grown in popularity, particularly in the United States, and has resulted in its own type of "contemporary" worship style. This style of contemporary service has become an alternative for mainline churches not interested in fundamentalism and/or gospel music. In addition, many of these mainline churches have also developed a growing interest in contemplative prayer and meditation.

- In the last decade of the 20th century (and continuing in the 21st century) many churches have struggled with which type of worship style is best suited to their needs. The main struggle seems to be between "traditional" vs. "contemporary", particularly as it relates to the MUSICAL STYLE:

1. those who want to continue with the traditional styles of worship practiced in the past as exemplified by such things as pipe organs, hymn books and traditional hymns or new hymns written in a traditional (i.e., classical) style. The American Guild of Organists has established goals and principles for preserving traditional (i.e., Western European) forms of worship. Here is an excerpt from their "Declaration of Religious Principles" :

"... We believe that at all times and in all places it is our duty to work and pray for the advancement of Divine Worship in the holy gifts of strength and nobleness; to the end that God's house may be purged of its blemishes, that the minds of all may be instructed, that the honor of that house may be guarded in our time, and in the time to come..." (see the complete statement here or here).

2. those who want to move to a contemporary service exemplified by instruments other than a pipe organ (especially electronic instruments and drums), easily memorized choruses or projected lyrics, no hymnbooks (or indeed, nothing held in the hand), and a contemporary musical style such as contemporary Christian music or "new-age music" (what an unfortunate term).

- As described above, "contemporary" does not mean the same thing to everyone. For churches in a fundamentalist or pentecostal tradition it means contemporary GOSPEL complete with "worship team", "worship leader", "praise band" (and in particular, DRUMS -- as in a drum set in a pop/rock band) and overhead projector for "lyrics" so that hymnbooks are not necessary. For mainline churches it might mean contemporary (often experimental) classical, folk and/or new-age music, liturgical movement (dance), labyrinths, Tieze and/or Iona chants and choruses, artworks, banners, etc.

- A compromise of sorts seems to have been reached in many churches as they practice a style of worship called BLENDED WORSHIP -- a mix of all styles.

- The phenomenon of the struggle between worship styles (often in the same church) has been called worship wars and seems to be dominating the discussion in liturgics, worship, and church music. This is having a profound effect on the kind and scope of congregational song here at the start of the 21st century.

See Felix Hell and the Worship War
See The Worship Wars
See Menu Driven Worship
See Worship Essay #1
See Hymns to Choruses
See Christianity 101 - God Centered Worship


© 2001 Smith Creek Music
Site last updated: August 1, 2007