Overview of 20th Century British Hymnody

By the end of the 19th century changing aesthetic tastes in Britain meant that much of Victorian Hymnody was no longer meeting the musical and liturgical needs of worship leaders. See The Victorian Web. One factor which contributed to this situation was the preponderance of new texts, particularly translations from the Latin and German. In addition there began a fascination with old tunes such as Metrical Psalm tunes from before 1700 and ancient liturgical tunes such as plainsong. Historical scholarship and proto-musicology brought about a rediscovery of ancient traditions; folksong research led to the "discovery" of beautiful indigenous tune and many worship leaders wanted to incorporate all of these into the contemporary liturgy. Biblical higher criticism was growing in religious academic circles and eventually became the theological underpinning of the late 19th century. Generally, the scientific community smugly felt that all the interesting problems had been solved (with only a few loose ends to tidy up). This attitude so much went along with the Victorian ideal as expressed musically by the Part Song: comfortable and contented. However, the storm clouds of scientific, social, and artistic revolution (not to mention the "Great War") were just over the horizon.

In the last quarter of the 19th century, a group of British composers began writing tunes in a larger, more expansive style which proved to be the progenitor of a new type of 20th century tune. Two composers in particular stand out:

Hubert Perry (1848-1918)

INTERCESSOR (By gracious powers, UMH #517)
RUSTINGTON (H82 #367)

Charles V. Stanford (1852-1924)

ENGELBERG (When in our music God is glorified, UMH # 68. Originally associated with "For all the saints")

Although the ever-present Hymns Ancient and Modern published these and other similar tunes in its 1905 edition, they are known to us today mainly through the success of the The English Hymnal (1906).

Robert Bridges published the Yattendon Hymnal in 1899 which became a bridge between between the Victorian hymnody of the 1st half of the century and the modern hymnody of the last half. In this collection he preserved and restored many old British tunes, particularly metrical psalms, chorales, and plainsong tunes. Although his original intention had been to supply texts to these tunes from standard hymnals, he soon discovered that no existing texts matched the meters of his collected tunes and consequently, he set about translating texts from the Latin, German, and Greek. Several of these are now considered to be among the finest hymn texts in the English language:

Ah, holy Jesus (UMH #289)
All my hope on God is founded (UMH #132)

The Yattendon Hymnal was not a financial success (it was large, unwieldy and very expensive; however, it laid the ground work for Percy Dearmer and Ralph Vaughan Williams in their compilation of The English Hymnal (1906).

The English Hymnal (1906) is important in the development of 20th century English hymnody for a number of reasons:

See The English Hymnal
See Ralph Vaughan Williams

Other important hymn collections after the English Hymnal and before about 1955:

Songs of Praise (1926)
Church Hymnary (1927)
The Oxford Book of Carols (1928)
The BBC Hymn Book (1950)
Hymns Ancient and Modern Revised (1950)
Congregational Praise (1951)

The period 1955 - 1970 was a time of "crisis" in British hymnody and church music. There was much experimentation with hymns (and other church music) in a popular style, specifically to attract youth. Here are some of the most important contributors:

The Church Light Music Group, of which Geoffrey Beaumont is the most well known:

20th Century Folk Mass
GRACIAS (Lord, thy word abideth -- S&BG)
CHESTERTON (Now thank we all our God -- S&BG)

[In addition to the 20th Century Folk Mass, between 1955 and about 1970 other POP-music masses were created, particularly in the USA. Here is a short list:]

Rejoice - about 1963 (students of the General Theological Seminary of the Protestant Episcopal Church USA)
The American Folk Mass - about 1963 (The Rev. Ian Douglas Mitchell, St. Anns' Episcopal Church, Chicago,IL, USA)
A Youth Folk Mass - about 1965 (Grace Cathedral, San Francisco, CA, USA)
Mass for Young Americans - 1966 (Raymond Robert Rep, St. Louis Preparatory Seminary, St. Louis, MO, USA)
Misa Bossa Nova - 1966 (St. Brendan's Parish, Chicago, IL, USA)
Won't You Pass It Along - 1964 (Berkeley Divinity School, Episcopal Seminary, New Haven, CT, USA)
An American Mass - about 1965 (Rev. Joseph Rivers, Roman Catholic Diosese of Cincinnati, OH, USA)

Another important movement in Great Britain after the The Church Light Music Group was a folk music revival lead by Sidney Carter (b. 1915).

Lord of the dance (SIMPLE GIFTS -- UMH # 216)
Every Star Shall Sing a Carol (H53)

By about 1963, British hymnody had become somewhat "stagnant" as evidenced by Erik Routley's comment in an article in The Hymn concerning the New English Renaissance. However, after about 1970, there was an "explosion" of new English hymns which continues today.


Home
Check out 100 Hymn Tunes You Should Know

© 2001 Smith Creek Music

Site last updated: February 15, 2007